[ad_1]
(This post contains some mega-spoilers for "Avengers: Endgame." Seriously, we'll talk in detail about the very last scene in the movie here.)
Everyone knew that in "Avengers: Endgame", Chris Evans was about to leave the franchise after this one. It's been a problem for a while – when he finished filming, he freaked out fans with a kind of crying goodbye tweet that made everyone think that Captain America was going to die.
But we did not know what all that really meant – we just knew we knew that "Endgame" would be Steve Rogers' last race as Captain America, but we did not know if that meant that he would die or die. if anything else would do it. happen. It turns out that they left with something else and that it has no narrative or thematic sense.
Read also: These are the time travel rules of & # 39; Avengers: Endgame
(Hey, then, detractors are about to sink freely here, so if you're a person who does not want to know what's going on but has managed to get so far anyway, you should probably leave.)
(Why are you still reading this?)
So, what they found for Steve's release really reflects the fan theory that has circulated for a while: that Steve would travel in 1945 and live his life in peace with Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell) before to show himself again in the present as an old man. That is, apparently, exactly what he did. But that's not a good ending for Cape, it's just weird and totally out of character. And that does not work with the time travel rules set by the movie. Let's break it down.
Let's start with the most important problem: Captain America has trouble supporting his work, and especially to give way to such work. Going to the past to retire with Peggy would mean that he has to sit still while all kinds of bad things happen, which he knows will happen. Hydra is at the forefront, taking control of SHIELD and fomenting all kinds of ills. He lives the good life while Bucky (Sebastian Stan) is used and abused as a Winter Soldier for 70 years.
Read also: & # 39; Avengers: Endgame & # 39; – We must talk about this situation of black widow
With great power comes great responsibility, and Cap has chosen to spend the vast majority of his life not taking his responsibilities? Also, remember the "I'm with you at the end of the line" set between him and Bucky? I guess it was not real. Cape, at around 39, if he takes his time off the ice, just give up and relax until he's too old to continue helping. It's just not something Steve Rogers, as we've learned in the last eight years, would do. And it's insulting to the character not only to put him in the pasture that way, but to let him choose.
And on top of all that, this scene does not make any sense because of the way it showed up at the end. According to the rules of time travel set up by "Avengers: Endgame" itself, Cape back in the past and to hear with Peggy would create a divergent time line and it would no longer be part of the game. universe of films. Which would mean that to go back to the current timeline of "Endgame", he should use his travel device in time.
If Cape appeared as an old man on the platform of time travel, this scene could unfold according to the rules of the film. But since he was right on a bench when they noticed it, it seemed to imply that he simply lived his life and presented himself at the right time. It certainly does not carry the travel device in time in this scene.
Read also: & # 39; Avengers: Endgame & # 39; – All you need to know about the Asgardians of the Galaxy
And since Cape Town is probably too old-fashioned to engage in polyamory, his marriage to Peggy would probably mean that she never married the man she married in the main storyline and that her children never exist. Steve has accidentally returned to the past and erased Peggy's children from the story. That does not seem to be a thing for Steve Rogers either.
I heard the argument that Steve could have been Peggy's husband, whose name was not mentioned, who was mentioned in "Winter Soldier" all this time, and who does not fit no more to the rules established by the film. When our heroes roam the past in "Endgame", they create new versions of events rather than doing what was happening in the background of previous movies we did not know. This does not mean that the quantum mechanics of the MCU, as demonstrated in the rest of this film, would be different only for Cap.
On top of all that, let's take even more risks by pointing out that when Cape went off to bring back the Infinity Stones where the Avengers had taken them, he only went with the literal stones. Which is quite problematic because he would need to restore them in their original form, not in the form of crystals. So the stone of space must be the Tesseract cube. The mental stone should be in the scepter. Reality Stone should be a liquid that should be reinjected into Jane Foster (?!?!) One way or another. The Power Stone would be in its orb shell.
I can not even begin to guess how we could put the soul stone back in its place on Vormir. But the Stone of Time, at least, he could simply pass to the Old One as is.
Read also: & # 39; Avengers: Endgame & # 39; – What happened with Loki and Tesseract?
And do not even get me started on the logistics of returning the stones at the exact moment they were taken, as Hulk asks, without any help.
So, yes, all of this is a super weird mess. As a human being, it does not fit at all in Cape Town, and it does not fit with the rules of time travel, and it really does not seem so well thought out, by opting for an emotional support service at the expense of narrative coherence type. They should have just killed "Captain America" in the final battle in "Avengers: Endgame" instead. That would have saved me at least the trouble of having to analyze all these things.
[ad_2]
Source link