Federal judge dismisses some of Apple’s allegations in fight against Epic Games

US Legal News

Reuters staff

(Reuters) – A California federal judge dismissed some of Apple Inc’s counterclaims against Epic Games on Tuesday evening, in a dispute that saw the online gamemaker’s game ‘Fortnite’ removed from the manufacturer’s app store iPhone.

Apple and Epic have been in a legal battle since August, when the popular game maker launched its own integrated payment system to bypass what it called Apple’s monopoly practices.

In October, Epic filed a motion ahead of Tuesday’s hearing, asking for the dismissal of Apple’s counterclaims for intentional interference with potential economic benefit and conversion, while Apple asked for the loss of costs from the App Store and other pecuniary damages.

“It is hereby ordered that John I. Karin’s request be granted,” US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers said in Tuesday’s filing, referring to Epic’s attorney’s request.

A judge in October ruled that Apple could ban Epic’s “Fortnite” game from its App Store but should not interfere with the business of Epic’s development tools, including “Unreal Engine” software, which is used by hundreds of other video games.

“This is a high-stakes breach of contract and antitrust case and that’s it in my opinion,” US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers told lawyers, according to Bloomberg.

“You can’t just independently say it’s illegal,” Bloomberg said, citing bloom.bg/3pgZDlx, the judge at Apple attorney, referring to Epic’s behavior. “You actually have to have facts,” the judge said, adding that the rest of the breach of contract case was moving forward.

Apple and Epic did not respond to Reuters’ request for comment. The iPhone maker told Bloomberg it disagreed with the judge’s ruling on Tuesday, adding that it was clear Epic had severed its contract with the company.