[ad_1]
This is probably the video game release of the year. The video game will be under many fir trees in a few weeks. The world's press continues to braid laurels Red Dead Redemption 2, the game that offers you, as in the series Westworld, to immerse yourself body and soul in the America of cowboys and saloons.
The first installment, released in 2010, had already won over a large part of the public and critics for its quality. Rockstar Games, the American studio has who have it must cult series Grand Theft Auto, so reissued the feat with a sequel. The game has received, since its release on October 26, 2018, spectacular notes: 8/10 at Gamekult, 19/20 at jeuxvideo.com, 5 stars for The Guardian, 10/10 for IGN and even 21/20 for the site JeuxActu…
And it's not just a story of journalists. After only three days of marketing, the game had generated more than $ 725 million by becoming the second most lucrative launch in video game history behind the record Grand Theft Auto V which had reached the level of one billion in 72 hours of marketing. The last game to have been so successful is probably The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild which accompanied the launch of the Nintendo Switch. 53 tests of this masterpiece of March 2017 gave the title the maximum score.
The two games also share many elements: a hero, a gigantic open world, a horse to cover these vast expanses … Despite these similarities, it is clear that the new baby of Rockstar is a game diametrically opposed in its design and the pleasure that it can provide to the players. Fans of one could quickly be exhausted by the other …
The strength of a movie script
Red Dead Redemption 2 is before an immense western, a film of which you are of hero. With your hero, the taciturn and always efficient Arthur Morgan, you wander wild West United States. You are not alone in your journey, a whole band of characters often endearing and colorful accompany you. The famous Dutch band. Your family for the 50 or 100 hours that you will spend in the game. Convicts, rebels and other marginalized …
The game is very much based on the atmosphere, the main story and dialogues very many (always in English, but it is the language of Americans so everything sticks). The staging does not hesitate to talk silences, looks, to be slow and contemplative when other games are turned mainly to action.
In Breath of The Wild, you run, you climb, you fight and complete dungeon after dungeon in a quasi religious silence. Red Dead Redemption 2 offers dozens of hours of dialogue recorded and played with talent, trips on horseback, on foot or horse drawn punctuated exchanges. A mode can even activate the black bands at the top and bottom of your screen for an effect "like in the movies". The camera will then follow your hero with more artistic points of view. A real movie (without the ellipses).
There is no doubt the great strength of Red Dead Redemption 2 and the biggest fault of the last Zelda : a rich, dense story, with twists and a real narrative talent. It's the story (certainly linear) that drives you to continue Red Dead while Breath of The Wild considered his own story as a pretext, a very optional element.
In this game, it is for example possible to run from the first hour to the final boss and finish the game at once. Freedom is total. Such a thing is totally unthinkable in Red Dead Redemption 2. A very beautiful, strong and rigorous thread must be followed.
Rehabilitation by ergonomics
Red Dead Redemption 2 sees a major criticism come back in the mouths of the players: the controls. The designers of the game were keen to make the player's experience very realistic … and counter-intuitive. The character for example moves very slowly, he walks and runs rarely. Shooting with a rifle, a bow or throwing his lbado on horseback is not a trivial gesture.
These actions provoke reactions in other characters and sometimes you have to press three buttons to finally start an action. We choose his weapon, we wear it, we draw, we aim, we shoot, we recharge … And these gestures take time. A habit to take.
There is not only the problem of time wasting (because who really enjoys traveling in a gigantic world at the speed of a sick snail?). The game also asks the player toforget his habits. The controls are different from the standards of the other games. The first few hours are spent looking at the bottom right of the screen to find out which button to press for this or that result.
An example: objects. Ammunition is recovered by walking on it, money and items with another button, your hat with another one … It's like playing a game of combat or choreography manipulations are raging. The menus are also very convoluted and difficult to maneuver. Your brain wants to perform an action, but everything is done to counter your will. And it's not very nice.
The goal is to slow down the player's paceto make him aware of the gestures and to bring him closer to real life. Only problem: by removing the players' reflexes, Red Dead Redemption 2 makes his players leave his world. Zelda: Breath of The Wild on the contrary was a monument of ergonomics. Displacements, objects, abilities, environment and interactions were a pleasure of every moment and a great source of inventiveness for the players.
Realism vs fantastic
It's a safe bet that fans of Red Dead have a hard time accepting the storyline flaws and physical inconsistencies of Zelda. And vice versa. Those who enjoyed the great freedom of action and incredible fluidity of Breath of The Wild will probably have some impatience with rigid realism cowboys from Rockstar Games.
Despite the very similar style of the two games – epic adventures in gigantic worlds open to ride on horseback – the two titles remain very related to their genre. The western for one and the fantasy for the other.
To find out if any of these games are right for you, you probably need ask yourself what you find the most ridiculous A hero who can carry 45 bombs, 8 bows, 7 swords and 6 axes in a bag or hero who has to turn 3 times around his horse and press five different buttons to simply put a revolver in his inventory.
As for the rest, games are artistically successful. The photorealism of Red Dead It's incredible and the artistic direction of Zelda very charming. The work on colors, lights, sound effects and music is considerable, admirable even. Both games have undeniable qualities and can claim the status of masterpiece. But the masterpiece of some is not that of others.
Read more
Source link
