[ad_1]
"There are three types of lies: lies, accursed lies and statistics," said British Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli, according to author Mark Twain
. the honor for the song "In My Life" from the album Rubber Soul from 1965.
As long as the sun shone and idyllic the council in the camp of the Beatles, they two writers were in agreement that everything they put together should be signed with "Lennon / McCartney."
That does not mean that they were in the same room and wrote new songs from scratch. The clearest is that the melody or text comes from one of them.
– Lennon typically wrote melodies without much variation, says Mark Glickman of Harvard University in a press release
. Find out who "really" wrote the different songs. After the break in 1970, McCartney and Lennon regularly published articles on their own contributions and those of others.
Almost 100% think it's Lennon
Pretty much "In My Life", they found contradictory versions of myths of creation. The text is Lennon's, but they both claimed the melody.
– John wrote the text, and I added him a melody, according to The Telegraph newspaper
Now the Glickman statistician thinks it's a Lennon Melody
– The probability that "In My Life "was written by McCartney is 0.018,
it's less than 2%, and Glickman is convinced that Lennon is behind the melody.
Data Model
Glickman and his colleagues fed all Lennon / McCartney production between 1962 and 1966 into advanced data models . Each song is broken down into 149 different musical characteristics, and it is there that they think they can find what is typical of Lennon and what is typical of McCartney.
For the sake of good: this does not prove that McCartney wrote "In my life". This is only statistically improbable. (But then that was once again statistics.)
Glickman also has a gift for McCartney. The song "The Word", also that of Rubber Soul, he was sure to come from Lennon. But according to the data model, it's almost certainly a McCartney song.
Glickman presents the Beatles statistics at the Joint Statistics Meetings conference this week. It is not yet published in peer-reviewed journals
Source link
