[ad_1]
Back from the west coast, Gabe Kapler defended Jean Segura on Friday morning in a radio interview with Angelo Cataldi of WIP.
As was the case during previous Kapler-Cataldi confrontations, listening was not comfortable. Cataldi has bombarded the Phillies manager with tough questions but mostly just about Segura's poor performance leading to Andrew McCutchen's ACL tear.
As a reminder, Segura threw a ball on the right side of the infield with McCutchen in first base Monday in San Diego. Segura knelt on his swing and then did not rush to the first goal. Veteran Alert Ian Kinsler saw this and dropped the ball, getting the first-strike out before starting a weakening in which McCutchen crashed his knee awkwardly and was injured. .
Segura has been a scapegoat by some for the injury. Not by the Phillies themselves or even by McCutchen, but by some of the fans. Part that Cataldi probably misrepresented when he told Kapler that "the whole city, everyone thinks that's the reason".
Kapler does not see this as a simple cause-and-effect scenario. It is true that if Segura had run, the disrepair might never have occurred. It is also true that if a ball aimed at McCutchen was called a shot, he might not have walked to lead the match and would not have been to first base to start. Or if the Padres second base player was not an experienced veteran, the situation is the same as it does 99 times out of 100, with the second baseman simply grabbing the popup.
That's how baseball is. That's one of the reasons I can not stand up when everyone, including advertisers, looks back at a match after it's finished and says, "They lost 6-5, but if that was not their first track with two points, they would have won! "Well … no, because without this circuit in the first run, the whole sequence of events that follows is different – from field selection to intensity and strategy.
That does not mean that Segura is irreproachable. He accepted the responsibility of not shoving. He was not on the bench, because Kapler told Cataldi: "This would not make Segura better and the Phillies better." It's hard to argue that given the fall between Segura and whoever l? 39 would have replaced at the immediate stop for a game or two.
Cataldi accused Kapler of being disconnected from the fan base. It's true that a radio host who spends hours every day of the week interacting with fans is, by nature, more connected to what they say than an athlete or a manager at a few steps away.
However, Kapler says that Cataldi is right, that the size of the sample of callers on the radio or those who respond angrily on Twitter does not indicate all the fans. Most sports fans do not rush on the airwaves or feel compelled to participate in online discussions. Personally, I experiment it all the time, where I'm going to gather a few hundred responses to one of my tweets that says that the fan base is felt in a certain way, and that I have a different experience when I talk with Phillies fans in person at the stadium or around the city.
The sports media landscape can be a bubble. We usually hear only fans who feel passionate in one way or another – not fans with more measured and less exciting shots.
It is safe to say that many more WIP callers wanted to impress Segura that "Yeah, that was a defining event, but that was not the direct reason why McCutchen tore up his access control list. ".
And those who hold the most measured opinion, their comments are not as entertaining and, therefore, they may not have passed call screening. The controversy is selling in almost every facet of the media.
Here's a transcript of Friday's interview:
Kapler: "What I see happened, as I said, [Segura] stumbled out of the box. He did not have his feet under him. Once he regained his balance, he was no longer able to run as hard as he usually does. He recognized it and speaking of gratitude, I recognize it. He can do a better job getting out of the penalty area. Recognizing also that our center player at the time, our head hitter, had been significantly injured. I say that it is not Segura 's fault and say that it is absolutely irresponsible. "
Cataldi: "Oh, yes? So, you better tell it to the whole town, because everyone thinks that's the reason."
Kapler: "Angelo, you do not speak for the whole city."
Cataldi: "I talk to a lot more fans than you."
Kapler: "You talk to the guys who call, men and women who call."
Cataldi: "And those who write to me and those who are on Twitter, and all the other people." Do you want to tell me that you are more connected to this city than me? You've been on the west coast for a week, Gabe. "
Kapler: "I'm going to tell you this: What you're hooked up to is the people who call your show, all Philadelphia fans as you represent them."
Cataldi: "We actually surveyed this question and 85% of respondents said that Segura should be held responsible much more than yourself, so it's more than five or six thousand people." not enough for you, Gabe? Realize you're not in tune with what's happening in your city. "
Kapler: "Your sample, the one you're shooting at, is a very specific sample."
Cataldi: "Last thing, would you do something different this week, Gabe?"
Kapler: "I may have handled this show a little differently.I'm very frustrated by you.At this moment, I am quite disturbed.I think you have not treated this show in a fair and reasonable way. , and that's probably what I'm most disappointed is the way you handled this show. "
Cataldi: "I'm disappointed with some of the answers, so I guess we're equal in that."
Click here to download the MyTeams app from NBC Sports! Get complete coverage of your teams and easily play Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games on your device.
More on the Phillies
[ad_2]
Source link