[ad_1]
- Bennett said that the statement "describes the alleged systematic actions of the Polish government in exile and other Poles in order to help members of the Jewish people." This file does not correspond to reality. "Polish activities were rare and non-central"
- he acknowledged that "rare manifestations of benevolent actions are transferred to the entire nation, (…) helping Jews in Poland was a relatively rare phenomenon ( …) more frequent were the situations in which the Poles betrayed the members of the Jewish nation "
- Apart from the removal of the worst provisions of the law on the IPN, which threatened to imprison people With a different view of Judeo-Polish relations during the war, the Polish and Israeli prime ministers issued a joint statement. Its form was negotiated, which had to satisfy both parties and end the conflict, which was useless for any government with enough other problems.
From the beginning, it was known that the Israeli prime minister was one of the last to oppose Poland. international interests. The Israeli government is no less populist than Polish. Let us not forget that the criticism of Poland in the world began with the Israeli opposition, not the government.
Netanyahu joined him when he had no choice. He knew perfectly well that he could lose an important ally because Poland was by far the most faithful to the EU, Israel, among others. because of their loyalty to the United States, a common ally.
That is why the statement included on the one hand fragments pointing out that Germany and anti-Polonism condemning (apart from condemning anti-Semitism) are solely responsible for the camps of concentration and death. And on the other hand, the admission of the Polish side that there were "individual cases of cruelty to the Jews". And immediately a reminder of the righteous among the nations. The whole passage reads as follows: "We recognize and condemn each case of Polish cruelty committed by the Poles during the Second World War. We proudly remember the heroic deeds of many Poles, especially the Righteous among the Nations, who risked their lives by saving the Jews. How many "some people" on the dark face?
About szmalcownikach (as I suppose) remembers in an extremely veiled way, about actually nobody knows, rather generally bad people: "Sad truth is unfortunately such that in this time some people – regardless from the origin, religion or belief – have revealed their darkest face. "" We appreciate the fact that the structures of the Polish underground state overseen by the Polish government in exile have created a mechanism of help and systemic support for people of Jewish origin, and the clandestine courts have issued Polish convictions for cooperation with I am really sorry, but the Israeli Minister Naftali Bennett is right when he criticizes the "statement describes the alleged systematic actions of the Polish government in exile and other Poles to help the members of the nation."
This file does not conform to reality.
Polish actions were few in number and not of central character. "He is also right, saying that there were Poles who helped the Jews, but there were" few "such people, and further on:" In other words, rare manifestations of Benevolent actions are moving towards the entire nation … the historical reality is that helping Jews in Poland was a relatively rare phenomenon. "
This is evidenced by exceptionally insightful research (the poviat of the poviat has been studied), on which the book in two volumes "Next is the night, destiny of the Jews in the chosen poviats of occupied Poland" edited by Barbara Engelking and Jan Grabowski of the Center for Research on the. Holocaust of the Jews According to their estimates, two out of three seeking to rescue Jews (after the liquidation of ghettos sought in towns and villages) were killed, mainly Polish hands or with the help of Poles. two out of three of the 250,000 who are flee to the Nazis (6 million Jews were killed during the Holocaust)
As a Prof. Grabowski in one of the interviews: "It is still dark" asks the PiS argued that the Poles have massively saved the Jews during the war. On the contrary, this book makes us aware of the immensity of the Jewish tragedy, to which the Poles have also contributed. Thus, mentioning all the critical claims of the Polish-Jewish history of the 6600 Polish trees of Yad Vashem (who also rejected the Polish-Israeli declaration) falsifies more than anything else. Also considering the fact that the camps of the died were built by the Germans on the territories of the destroyed Polish state, where more than three million Jews lived before the war, where the majority would come from "just among the nations of the world"?
so that the terms "Polish" and "Poland" have not deliberately stated in the statement (as it was not stated, about which "some people" the black language is supposed to speak). In order to be able to decide freely what was Polish and Polish, and this is not the case, it is a common practice among right – wing politicians, and it turns out that Poland does not. did nothing to the Jews, because Poland could do nothing wrong. If she did, it would not be Poland, so it was not Poland who did it. Therefore, there is no question of Poland's responsibility for everything that happened to the Jews. That's why 1968 is the reason for … pride, not shame.
The beautiful verbal gymnastics of the first
Recall the words of Prime Minister Morawiecki with an anniversary speech in March 68: "We often hear today 68 should be our reason for shame, I think that everything d & # 39; First, March 68 for Poland, for the Poles who fought for freedom, should be a source of pride and not a cause of shame (…) it is clear that this situation this country does not have a lot of … was not an independent state, a sovereign state. "And it is certainly the Soviet Union that ordered the Poles to attract the stars of David on the door of the neighbors of Jewish origin, to ask for a real name, to get rid of the and this part, which is unreal but true, has nothing to do with the Free Poles, with Poland who wanted freedom and who s'. is beaten for this freedom, is also beaten and especially in March 68 "- said our Prime Minister C & # 39; is probably why the IPN censor the photos of KOR members to cover the face of & # 39; Adam Michnik, that is why he does not react to acts of anti-Semitism, like burning a Jewish effigy in Wroclaw, and probably for the sake of the protagonists the supporters of the shameful PiS Władysław Bartoszewski, who helped the Jews during the war
A critical look at the Polish history of the Israeli Minister of Science Naftal i Bennett, Professor Grabowski and Professor Engelking or mine does not mean that Poles are more or less good than others, they are more or less the same. says Timothy Snyder, a historian who can not be suspected of anti-Polish, Polish behavior "they behaved more or less like others in similar circumstances." By definition, heroism is a rare or very rare behavior. Otherwise, it would not be socially recognized. If the whole nation were heroic, he would not even know that there are other possibilities.
Jarosław Kaczyński and Mateusz Morawiecki are fighting needlessly for the good reputation of the nation. As Władysław Bartoszewski mentioned, "when he saved Jews, he never asked for the consent of the Polish nation before."
Do you want to keep up to date with the most important information of the day? Like onet News on Facebook!
(ks)
Source link
