[ad_1]
- Yad Vashem has today criticized the joint statement of Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki and Benjamin Netanyahu
- "The historical theorems in the joint statement (Prime Ministers) presented as undeniable facts contain serious errors and distortions" – stresses the institute
- Dina Porat institute – said "Jerusalem Post"
- Journalists of the "Jerusalem Post" did not get comment Porat
This is reported by the newspaper "Jerusalem Post quoting Jaakov Nagel and Joseph Ciechanower, who prepared this statement. In response to criticism, Yad Vashem issued a statement in which they stressed that the "historic claims" contained in this statement were approved by her.
"Jerusalem Post" writes that it was not possible to obtain a comment from Porat
The statements contained in the document are inconsistent with current historical knowledge.
As stated in a statement posted on the Institute's website, "a thorough analysis by historians Yad Vashem shows that the historical claims in the joint statement were undeniable facts they contain errors and distortions grave. "
The Institute stresses that the joint statement of heads of government" contains very problematic sentences that are inconsistent with current and valid historical knowledge in this area ". These statements are part of the narrative, "which scientific research has long refuted, namely that the Polish government in exile and its clandestine armed forces tirelessly sought – in occupied Poland and not only – to thwart the extermination of Polish Jews. "
Israeli Statement
According to the statement of Morawiecki and Netanyahu, the government in exile created a "mechanism for systemic help and support for people of Jewish origin" and took steps decisive against the Poles who denounce the Jews. Yad Vashem notes that "although the statement mentions cases of crimes committed by Poles against Jews, we are also talking about many Poles who risked their lives to save Jews."
"Existing documents and decades of Historical research gives a completely different picture: The Polish government in exile with its seat in London and the (the country's) government office has never acted decisively in favor of Polish citizens of Jewish origin during the war. Much of the Polish resistance movement has not only failed to help the Jews. she actively participated in their persecution, "says Yad Vashem in a polemic with the text of the statements of Prime Ministers of Poland and Israel
The Institute also notes the difference in the magnitude of the help to the Jews and the persecution. "Three decades of historical research here also show a completely different picture: helping the Jews of the Poles was relatively rare, and the attacks and even the murders of Jews were a common phenomenon," we read. Yad Vashem points out that the "impressive" actions of the Jewish aid Żegota, backed by the Polish government in exile, "can not be translated into Polish society as a whole" or "generally attributed to the institutions of the Polish resistance movement" [L'analysedeladocumentationetdelarecherchemontrequemêmelesPolonaisquiessayaientd'aiderlesJuifstourmentésavaientpeurdeleursvoisinspolonaisnonmoinsquelesoccupantsallemandstentantdeglorifierl'aidedonnéeauxJuifsetdelaprésentercommeunphénomènecommunLesJuifssontnonseulementcontrelavéritéhistoriquemaisaussicontrelamémoiredel'héroïsmedesJustesparmilesNations"écritYadVashemsurladéclarationdeschefsdegouvernementdePologneetd'Israëlsignéele27juin
s review & # 39; content Institute in the document not that" some people – regardless of their origin, their religion or belief – revealed their darkest face ". According to Yad Vashem, "the tragedy that met the Jews with its specific historical context and the realities of Poland occupied during the war" is separate. Yad Vashem believes that it is "a scandalous insinuation that the Jews then revealed their" darkest face "and points out that those who revealed the darkest face" n & # 39; 39 were not deprived of identity. "They were Poles and Catholics and collaborated with the German occupiers, whom they hated, persecuting Polish citizens of Jewish origin," stresses the Institute of Memory of Martyrs and Heroes of the Catholic Church. Holocaust
Yad Vashem also strongly opposes to "compile the anti-Semitism phenomenon with so-called" anti-polonism. "Mentioned in the statement of heads of government.It was noted that although the use from the erroneous expression "Polish death camps" to be deleted, "to use terms such as" anti-polonism "is completely anachronistic and has nothing to do with anti-Semitism." [19659016] In his statement, Yad Vashem On June 27, the Polish authorities removed Article 55a imposing fines and jail sentences for the assignment of responsibility to the nation and to the country. Polish state for the crimes of the Third Reich and Article 55b for r Polish citizens, a stranger "regardless of the rules in force at the place where the act was committed."
Then in response to these actions, Yad Vashem described them as "not positive in the right direction ". (these articles, with the amendment of 27 June – PAP), however removes an exclusion they were included in the wording of the amendment (from January), scientific research and artistic projects " "Other provisions (the current amendment), which remained unchanged, allow the civil law" to prosecute for violation of the Polish and Polish nation's reputation – the institute believes. the Prime Minister assured that people from education or education would not be subject to legal liability, "but this was not clearly stated" in the amendment from June to the IPN Law – Yad Vashem's claims and the public discourse on historical issues to a state narrative unalterable by legal provisions and sanctions is inappropriate and constitutes a clear violation (freedom – PAP) of scientific research ", stresses Institute of Memory of the Martyrs and Heroes of the Holocaust. Do you keep up to date with the most important information of the day? Like onet News on Facebook!
(sp)
Source link
