[ad_1]
Be honest, a few days after seeing A Star Is Born, which song do you hum the most? Is it the "Shallow" duo, immediately emblematic of Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga? Is it Gaga's power ballad "Always remember us this way"? Or it's "Why did you do that?" Who has the now famous phrase "Why do you come around me with a donkey like this?
In the movie, Ally (Gaga) plays "Why Did You Do That?" In "Saturday Night Live," illustrating the character's transformation into a true pop star, much to the annoyance of Jackson Maine's mongering husband (Cooper). Many fans wondered and argued over whether this catchy song was supposed to be good, bad or maybe even bad that it's good.
This week, two songwriters ended the debate once and for all.
"I would never deliberately sit down to write a bad song, even though I guess I did some without trying to do it that way," said co-writer and nine-time Academy Award nominee , Diane Warren, in the New York Times published Friday. "It was a fun song and I love fun pop songs. All must not be serious all the time. "
Warren had actually made it clear on Twitter earlier this month that he was "not intending" to make the song sound bad, although she did not elaborate further at that time. the.
Paul Blair, who helped write and produce "Why Did You Do That?" (As well as other songs from the soundtrack) made similar comments to The Washington Post this week. He said the song was definitely not meant to be bad, but simply to sound "more bubbly and more traditional" to show Ally's career trajectory.
Blair and Warren felt that viewers would not necessarily have to agree with Jackson Maine's reflections on the song. Warren told The Times that she was happy to see a moment in the film when Ally defends herself after Maine has made fun of her pop-up.
"It must not be [Maine] think the music should be – music can be everything, "Warren said." It can be a serious song, it can be a pop song, it can be a song on a donkey. "
[ad_2]
Source link
