Brett Kavanaugh is not popular. It will probably be confirmed.



[ad_1]

Recent polls show that Americans are divided as to whether Kavanaugh should be confirmed. The most recent Gallup poll found that 40% of respondents think it should be and 36% oppose it. The division was even closer in an ABC News / Washington Post survey at 38% for confirmation and 39% against.
Usually, Supreme Court candidates are well loved even after intense confirmation hearings. Just after the announcement of Kavanaugh, I've collected the final popularity ratings of all Supreme Court candidates since Robert Bork before their vote of confirmation or their withdrawal. (No surveys have been done about Anthony Kennedy.)

The average net approval or the assessment of the favorability of these candidates was 20 percentage points.

Kavanaugh's net favor rating is just above zero right now. No such unpopular candidate as Kavanaugh has been confirmed in modern times. Harriet Miers withdrew her nomination after being chosen by President George W. Bush, while Bork was rejected after being nominated by President Ronald Reagan.

The low popularity of Kavanaugh certainly limits his potential to obtain Democratic votes. Once we control factors such as the qualifications of a candidate and his ideological distance from each senator, the popularity of a candidate has affected the number of votes received for confirmation. One of President George H.W. Bush's choices, Clarence Thomas, for example, would probably not have been confirmed without his strong ratings of popularity.

The problem for those who hope that Kavanaugh will fall, is that popularity is not the only thing that matters. Miers has withdrawn mainly because the Conservatives have complained about his qualifications. Bork was rejected by a Democrat-controlled Senate because his Conservative record was so vast.
Meet the protesters interrupting Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation hearing
Kavanaugh has neither one nor the other of these problems. He has been described as "well qualified" by the American Bar Association. Kavanaugh will also be voted by a Senate that is controlled by the Republicans.

When you combine the composition of the Senate and Kavanaugh's judicial profile, his current popularity rating is probably not low enough for Republicans to vote against him. He can even take a Democratic vote.

Now, the good news for Democrats is that candidates tend to see their popularity decrease after a confirmation hearing.

Bork, for example, initially had a one-point favorability rating in a Times Mirror poll. That's more than 10 points higher than when his popularity rating was found in a Los Angeles Times poll before the Senate voted on it.

Senators signal Kavanaugh looks solid to win confirmation

When I already wrote about Kavanaugh, I noticed that a Bork type popularity could be low enough for Kavanaugh to be rejected. More precisely, this would lead him on average to obtain 49 votes against 50 against.

This, however, was back when Senator John McCain was not healthy enough to be in Washington to vote on Kavanaugh's confirmation. In other words, at the time when Republicans had only 50 Senators for Democrats 49.

This week, Republican Jon Kyl was sworn in to take over McCain's seat. Kyl has a conservative voting record and was Kavanaugh's sherpa (that is, the experienced Washington insider to guide him in the confirmation process). There is virtually no chance of Kyl voting against Kavanaugh. This brings Kavanaugh to an average of 50 votes in a hypothetical scenario where his popularity matches the worst candidate at the end of the confirmation process.
A silent protest with a very strong message: Stop Kavanaugh

I guess it's possible that Kavanaugh becomes even more unpopular than Bork. In this highly partisan environment in which potential judges are much less likely to reveal their positions on issues of judicial importance than they were at the time Bork was being studied, it seems unlikely that Kavanaugh's public figures would change as much.

It is also possible that Kyl's connection with Kavanaugh would make him give up voting. Again, it looks more like a democratic fantasy than a potential reality.

At the end of the day, with 51 Republican senators, he is very likely to find himself before the Supreme Court.

[ad_2]
Source link