HIV-Resistant Babies ?: "Risky and ethically objectionable intervention" | The world | DW



[ad_1]

"Two beautiful Chinese girls, Lulu and Nana, came into the world a few weeks ago crying and as healthy as another baby," He Jiankui said in a video posted on Nov. 25 on YouTube.

According to He, genetic modification of embryos was performed with the new CRISPR-Cas9 technique, with the aim of making infants resistant to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).

The researcher Southern University of Science and Technology guarantees that genetic modification has been successful and that only one gene has been modified to prevent HIV infection. The identity of the babies and their parents was kept secret, but according to him, the father is HIV-positive and wanted to prevent their children from being discriminated against.

He explained that he and his team had convinced couples without children to participate in the experiments and had used the technique of fertilization. in vitro. Scientists have modified the genomes of 16 embryos to eliminate the CCR5 receptor because people who do not have one can not contract HIV.

DW: How realistic is this news from China?

Jan O. Korbel: The human genome can already be modified for a while. However, the European Union prohibits these experiments on its territory. There is still a lack of important basic information about the conditions under which this experiment was carried out. There is no publication on this subject and, as a result, there is no evaluation study that independently proves that this is scientifically verifiable.

What are the risks of manipulating the genome with CRISPR / Cas9?

The CRISPR / Cas9 method is a precise technique to use for a selected purpose, but genetic modifications outside this area can not be ruled out.

Scientists He Jiankui and Zhou Xiaoqin in their laboratory in Shenzhen, Guangdong Province.

Scientists He Jiankui and Zhou Xiaoqin in their laboratory in Shenzhen, Guangdong Province.

What are the advantages of CRISPR / Cas9?

This has advantages in basic research, for example. Researchers can make changes to virtually any part of the genome. Therefore, the genetic material can be studied much more specifically than before.

There are also very promising potential applications in applied research, for example in the production of bacteria for the dairy or wine industry and the cultivation of plants for consumption. Also in biomedicine, the CRISPR / Cas9 method will undoubtedly play an important role.

In the two girls' genetic material, the molecular receptor was eliminated, allowing the HI virus to enter the cell and infect it.

With the cut of a particular receptor, one tries to reproduce a natural mutation. Thus, those affected should not be able to develop AIDS. Such an intervention would be illegal in Europe without any documentation of the additional effects of the changes introduced.

This procedure is not only ethically objectionable but very risky. Try to prevent an infectious disease with a new method, although there are already protection options.

What is the risk that, during such an intervention, other important genes are also eliminated or damaged?

It is still impossible to estimate the long-term consequences. Since in this case the cutoff occurs simultaneously in many cells and may even vary from one cell to the other, the consequences are even more uncertain. Stem cell manipulation is also illegal in Germany and Europe.

Jan O. Korbel specializes in computer biology, human genetics and genomics. He is a scientist at the European Molecular Biology Laboratory in Heidelberg.

(JOV / CP)

Deutsche Welle is the international radio station in Germany and produces independent journalism in 30 languages. Follow us on Facebook | Twitter | YouTube |

[ad_2]
Source link