What 16 hours of Ken Burns 'Country Music' epic leaves out



[ad_1]

VSCountry music has had an identity crisis since it came out of the cradle. Call it diffuse or call it elastic, but it has always worked on two tracks: one was rough and one was smooth, one rooted in tradition, the other more modern.

Think of this happy August 1927 in Bristol, Tenn., When, two days apart, Jimmie Rodgers and the Carter family auditioned for the Victor Talking Machine Company (which would eventually become RCA Records). Ralph Peer, record producer and discoverer of the record company, immediately signed the two acts. It was a great week for country music. But the music of Rodgers and Carters, although similar, is based on different traditions. Rodgers seemed smoother, more commercial, like Tin Pan Alley injected with blues and a yodel. The Carters spoke more spirituals and traditional mountain music. But both called the white working public that record companies were just beginning to cultivate. So who was going to meddle with the stylistic differences when the records would sell?

Together, over the course of a century, these two strands sewed a durable quilt and wide enough to accommodate Bill Monroe and Lynn Anderson, Bakersfield's sound and country, violins and syrupy violins. Sometimes the two strains disagreed and sometimes the tension between the two genius works created. Another word for this, of course, is schizophrenic.

If you would like to see this study in several musical personalities displayed with fascinating details, watch Ken Burns' eight-part documentary about country music that will debut tonight (September 15th) on your local PBS affiliate. It's not as fun and surreal as any given performance from Grand Ole Opry or even Hee Hawbecause Burns just did not do anything wrong, but if you need a basic course in your country, that's it.

Burns covers the titans, leaving well-deserved legends like Rodgers, Hank Williams and Patsy Cline, and maybe a little too much for Johnny Cash, although you can see how the creators of the doc need Cash to connect disparate parts of their story: Cash, not only married to the Carter family, becoming a de facto member of the royal family of the genre, but also seeking to bring people like Bob Dylan into the country, gave historical concerts in Folsom and San Quentin jails, cause Native Americans, and also for many years was just a big hard to break pills.

And although Cash has never been the musical equal of singer-songwriters such as Haggard or Parton, it's at least a welcome exception to the rule that silently guides this documentary: the success on the radio.

Sometimes this thought seems almost stupid: if you were successful, you were important. Let the cash register be your guide. This is surely the impetus that has almost always motivated Nashville's musical establishment, but it does not need to influence as much. But so, and so Garth Brooks, incredibly popular, but musically uninteresting, gets an embarrassing amount of time on the screen, while Bill Monroe, one of the wildest but most awesome geniuses of any American music, occasionally receives a respectful nod.

Another point that Burns only makes implicitly and that I wish I had deepened: more than any other genre, the country is the creation of radio and the record business. Of course, the success of the charts determines who is sold and promoted in all genres. But almost every genre, from blues to jazz to rock and roll, existed as musical styles. before be engulfed by the music industry. By that I mean that jazz was strong before being published on the radio and that it would have continued to be jazz, whether the radio and the record directors were careful or not. On the other hand, the country did not exist as a category before the radio invented it more or less. People like the Carter family have played for themselves and their neighbors. It was all homemade. They were not professional musicians until the radio and RCA said so. Thus, the medium through which music has reached its audience has always had a disproportionate influence on the direction of music.

An ironic note to all of this: Chet Atkins, the music producer and record director most responsible for making the country as palatable to the public, burst into country music as an unknown guitarist supporting Mother Maybelle Carter and her Three girls.

All those who are very interested in the subject already know who will be the most intelligent: Willie Nelson, Dolly Parton, Merle Haggard, Rosanne Cash and Emmylou Harris. But Burns has discovered unlikely commentators who sometimes threaten to steal the show. Who could have known if Brenda Lee spoke so well, or Jeannie Seely, Ray Benson, Carlene Carter or Charlie Pride? Country music to his surprises.

But best of all is Marty Stuart, who, in addition to being a great musician and articulate music historian to whom he has devoted his life, also has a great story: when he was still a boy, he had told his mother was going to get married. the country's star Connie Smith one day, and several decades later, he did just that.

Looking at the doc, there were more times than I could count and would have liked Burns to come and shoot a Marty Stuart movie talking. His improvised remarks are just as insightful as anything in the voice-over script written by Dayton Duncan and read by Peter Coyote. As Shelby Foote was Burns Civil warMarty Stuart too Country music.

It is Stuart's responsibility to emphasize the aforementioned dichotomy between Jimmie Rodgers' blues and refinement and traditional Carters gospel music. It is Stuart who points out that Maybelle Carter has practically invented the country guitar sound.

Beginning the fifth episode, Stuart describes the musical melting pot of the Grand Ole Opry scene in the middle of the century: "All his children had come to the Mother Church of Country Music. It was almost like a badge of honor that you had to bring your culture with you to the table. That's why Bob Wills and his guys brought us Western music. That's why Hank Williams brought the South with him from honky tonks. Johnny Cash brought the black soil of Arkansas. Bill Monroe extracted music from bluegrass music from Kentucky. Willie Nelson brought his poetry from Texas. Patsy Cline brought her the heartache of Virginia. I mean, it was the most wonderful parade of sons and daughters in America that brought their hearts, souls and experiences, and it gave us a great era for country music. "

The episode five is perhaps the best part of the series. Covering the years when Haggard, Parton, Buck Owens, Loretta Lynn and George Jones and Tammy Wynette dominated the radio's playlists, it illustrates the moment when popularity and musical genius were only one. After this strong moment, the series, like the music it covers, loses steam.

[ad_2]

Source link