[ad_1]
The myths about "British scientists" are most often raised when the media do not explain the value of scientists' work in a sufficiently deep and intelligible way. The confusion is also caused by frankly obscurantist sources, who twist a completely scientific theory and right to life in a sensational and profitable way. It almost happened with the work of the professor of the Mogilev Institute of the Ministry of the Interior, candidate of the philological sciences Sergei Danilenko, whose article, unfamiliar with mythology, took for the next "new chronology" of Fomenko
Asgard: geographical location and ethnic attribution ", where he speaks of the possible location of Asgard on the territory of the fortress of Semibrate (the ancient city of Labrys) in modern Russia, but not the mythical city of the gods, but its real prototype, founded by Sindi-Ases, who later on in Germanic-Scandinavian mythology were turned into gods.
Sergei Danilenko points out that the location of Asgard is just a theory stated in a scientific article where nothing is stated categorically.The article is publicly available, and every specialist can participate in a discussion about it
-I wrote that aces first appeared on the Taman Peninsula at the end of the 7th century BC [nowadays Karsnodar laRussieaudetland of Kerch-Onlinerby] . Specifically, appears a population that, most likely, can be identified with aces, – the author comments on his work for the correspondent Onliner.by
The Ases s 39; install it in 39; mouth of the Tanais, throwing itself into the Black Sea. And to the west of it are the Vans, with whom the Aces fight first, then try to maintain partnerships. Tanais is considered a modern gift. But at that time he fell directly into the Black Sea and not into the sea of Azov. Danilenko refers to modern archaeological studies that confirm it.
The scientist badumes that the Aspurgian tribe, mentioned in various sources, can be badociated with the same Ases: As-puraukas – "resident of the fortress", "resident of the city of Ases". They separated from the Sindi tribe when Labrys-Asgard fell into decomposition. In the midst of them were warriors who wanted to earn money, controlled the Kerch Strait.
It is quite possible that competition with the Greeks forced some of the Aes to move north along the rivers. It can be badumed that it was small groups of soldiers who became the local aristocracy, elites among the less developed tribes. This does not mean that modern Germans or Scandinavians are descendants of the Ases, what are you! So you can not speak, – the scientist is sure. – The newcomers came into contact with the local population. The myths of these nationalities were mixed: for some, Asgard became a heavenly city, for some it remained very real.
The question of mythology is a vast question of migration of different population groups that led to the emergence of medieval Europe.
– For city dwellers and bystanders, Marvel Asgard is something that can not exist. But if we talk about mythology, then we do not take it from heaven, we read ancient works: "Old Edda", "Younger Edda" and "Circle of the Earth", which includes the "Saga of". ; Ingling ". In these three sources, two versions of Asgard are given. These are two equal traditions: one is divine, the other is more bbad. One by one, it is a kind of celestial kingdom, where the gods live. According to another, it is an ordinary land fortress, the ace came from Asia, and the leader of the gods Odin, dying of old age, asked to be pierced with a spear. There is no revelation in this. They are two equal traditions under the same cover, which exist side by side and are not in conflict, – says Sergei Danilenko
But can myths become the basis of historical scientific work?
– Completely about the myths can not be based. They may be tempted to rebuild, and the question of the accuracy of this process is a topic of discussion for scientists. Myth – it is information about the past we have, we can attach specific territories, take a closer look at the burials, local ornaments.
For example, in the myth, it is written that the Don (known in ancient times as Tanais) flows into the Black Sea. Now we know perfectly well that it flows in the sea of Azov. But the latest Russian-German archaeological expedition confirmed that the Don had actually fallen into the Black Sea for several centuries. Look, who was living there at that time? We compare historical data with myths and make conservative conclusions – the scientist summarizes.
Smartphones in the catalog Onliner.by
Our channel in Telegram.
Quick communication with the editor: read the public chat Onliner and send us an email to Viber!
Source link
