"I had to call Lora." The court reviewed the appeal of the doctors sentenced for the death of a patient with a sore throat



[ad_1]

The Gomel Regional Court College left the doctors' verdict unchanged, on the occasion of which Anatoly Kovalevich, 40, died at the Rechytsa District Hospital. In April, they were found guilty of irregularities in the performance of their professional duties, which led to recklessness in the death of the patient and, in disagreement with the district court's decision, appealed

. height =

The doctors did not admit their guilt and appealed, the defendants asked to stop the verdict in the case because they had not the elements of the crime. responsibilities. There is no direct communication between the patient's death and his actions. They also urged the court to consider such an atypical course of the disease, which caused laryngeal stenosis and death is impossible.

Nevertheless, a different opinion was solicited by the expert of the General Directorate of forensic examinations Tatyana Vinnikova

According to the expert, the stenosis of the larynx is not Was not developed at the speed of lightning and for several hours (medical documents say so) and the doctors were able to react to the worsening of the patient's condition

. It was May 21, 2016. The day before, Anatoly Kovalevich, with a diagnosis of "follicular angina", was admitted to the Infectious Diseases Department of Rechitsa District Hospital. After one day, his condition worsened. The man went to the post office to the nurses, then the doctors on duty and complained of pain, asked to call Laura, but his requests were ignored, and the doctor was not called – the hospital had a day leave. But for some reason, they summoned a psychiatrist. A few minutes before his death, the man again came into the waiting room at the doctor's office, he was asked to wait because the doctor was not there. "I have something stuck in my throat" – that's the last thing the man said, became blue, fell and died.

Anna, widow of Anna, two years proved the guilt of doctors, three times refused. the district court of Rechitsa said the cardiologist Tatyana Kravchenko and the therapist Ekaterina Shabetnik guilty of poor performance of their professional obligations, which caused the patient's death by recklessness. Each of them was sentenced to a restriction of liberty without reference to an institution of the open type for a period of three years (the prosecutor asked for four), a fine of 980 rubles and a deprivation of the right to engage in activities. for a period of five years. a civil suit against the district hospital demanding moral compensation. The court decided to pay him 60,000.

  Photo: Elena Bychkova "border =" 0 "data-x-height =" 756 "data-x-src =" https://img.tyt.by/n / regiony / 0c / 8 / sud_rechica_vrachi.jpg "data-x-width =" 1200 "data-y-height =" 453 "data-y-src =" https://img.tyt.by/720x720s/n/ regiony / Data / yud_rechica_vrachi.jpg "data-y-width =" 720 "data-zoom =" 1 "height =" 453 "hspace =" 0 "src =" https://img.tyt.by/720x720s/ / regiony / 0c / 8 / sud_rechica_vrachi.jpg "title =" Photo: Elena Bychkova "vspace =" 0 "width =" 720 "/> </p>
<p>  – In the clinic, he complains of a sore throat , further in the hospital made complaints about sore throat, temperature 38 degrees and shortness of breath, and then at 2 o'clock in the morning, the patient is examined by the therapist in connection with complaints of sore throat and difficulty at 10 o'clock – still complaints of pain in the throat, discomfort in the chest.In 12.05 the patient has a clinical death e, – the chronology of experts at the trial says.-Initially, with sore throat, the right conservative treatment was accepted.But at some point, When the patient worsens, the medical tactics need to be reviewed. But the doctors did not intervene and did not prescribe certain medical manipulations. </p>
<p>  – They had an oto-rhino-laryngologist on duty, was on call at home. But they did not call him, because, says one of the defendants, there was no evidence to call a narrow specialist. Was there really no evidence? – the judge clarifies with the expert </p>
<p>  – The indications for calling the ENT were, because the patient's condition has worsened. The treatment, which was done one day, was ineffective. It was necessary to call a specialist narrower </p>
<p>  The accused Kravchenko said that there was no breathing in the patient, and after a dropper with prednisolone, he s & # 39; He is improved and he is asleep. </p>
<p>  Five departments of the respiratory system of the upper respiratory tract. were in a state of edema. Therefore, if you say that the patient did not have a respiratory disorder, then I say that it contradicts the results of an anatomical autopsy. As a result, there was edema of the airways and their permeability was impaired. If the patient is asleep, it does not mean that he has recovered. </p>
<p>  – Can laryngeal stenosis be seen in the naked eye? – asked the expert the question of the defender of one of the accused </p>
<p>  – It can be seen with a special examination. The ENT doctor has special mirrors, tools. The therapist has neither the tools nor the skills. Therefore, in this situation, it was necessary to call an ENT doctor to examine the larynx and vocal cords, formulate a diagnosis and correct treatment tactics. </p>
<p>  The injured party's lawyer is also in agreement. He believes that the death of the patient was not caused by a medical error, but by the inactivity of the doctors. </p>
<p>  The decision of the Rechitsa District Court was left virtually unchanged by the regional court panel. With the only amendment, a ban on medical activities of five years has been replaced by a ban on medical practice (doctors can not work for them and nurses, for example) </p>
<p>  <img alt= [ad_2]
Source link