CDC guidelines for people vaccinated are “too timid” and “far too cautious”

by



[ad_1]

Another interesting point of contention between a leading, camera-friendly medical authority and Joe Biden’s new improved CDC. Former FDA chief Scott Gottlieb caused a stir last week when he warned the CDC not to be too careful with its advice for people vaccinated. Those who have been vaccinated * will * go out and do things, he reminded them, starting with seeing their grandchildren. The CDC had better recognize this and advise them how to do the things they want to do more safely than advise them not to do those things at all, which is an invitation to the public to completely ignore them. guidelines.

The CDC seemed to take Gottlieb’s advice to heart with today’s new recommendations – a bit. It’s okay to encounter low-risk unvaccinated people, like grandchildren, as long as you limit the gathering to one household, the agency said. But what about public spaces like restaurants? And travel after a year of being locked up? Still thumbs down for now.

Dr. Leana Wen, one of CNN’s best-known medical analysts, can’t help but sigh.

TV medical experts don’t like having the light of day between their recommendations and the CDCs during a pandemic, knowing that a consistent message is important in convincing the public to adopt certain behaviors. This is doubly true with a left-wing administration that has pledged to ‘restore science’ to the White House and not let politics shape its public health message – except when teachers’ unions demand it, of course. . For Gottlieb and now Wen to undermine the CDC in this way, they must be a firm believer that the agency is being too restrained to get people to get vaccinated. “The CDC is missing a major opportunity to tie immunization status to reopening guidelines. By coming out with such limited advice, they are missing the window to influence state and national policy, ”Wen said in an email to the PA today. She wants more access to public spaces for the vaccinated, it seems. “Reluctance to vaccines will be the main obstacle to herd immunity. We need to solve this problem by being clear about the freedoms that people will gain after vaccination, ”she said. tweeted yesterday.

Gottlieb made a similar point during his appearance on “Face the Nation” on Sunday morning:

“We cannot be so far behind the aspirations of the public that the guidelines themselves are ignored,” he said. “I think people rightly feel that the overall vulnerability is decreasing right now as more and more people get vaccinated, because we also have broader immunity to this virus from a previous infection. So people are going to want to start doing things. They’re going to want to start coming out more. And we have to take that into account in the way we deliver advice. “

A thought I had yesterday: Given that we know the percentages of the population in each state that received their first and second doses, why not tie in restrictions such as corporate capacity levels and mandate status? mask for vaccination marks? For example, after 25% get both snaps, businesses statewide are allowed to open at 50% capacity, no matter what their local authorities say. At 40 percent vaccinated, businesses are scaling up to 75 percent of their capacity. At 60%, all capacity limits are lifted and the mask mandate is canceled. I’m not sure if Wen has something similar in mind or if she just wants the CDC to encourage those vaccinated to resume public activities like eating inside and going to the theater. It would be easy enough for the agency to issue guidelines recommending that those who have been vaccinated feel free to return to public spaces while those still awaiting their turn should avoid them. This would strongly encourage vaccination among the recalcitrant. But some unvaccinated and extremely risk-neutral people would also exploit the new rule to return to public spaces, mistakenly claiming they have been vaccinated, and some infections would occur that way. There must be a way to limit public spaces to those vaccinated, even if it is simply a matter of asking for their card (easily falsified) showing that they have received both doses.

It looks like we’re heading towards a “benchmark” system soon, according to this CNN segment airing this afternoon. Watch Sanjay Gupta at 2:15 a.m. here, reporting that new guidance is expected to come from the CDC periodically as vaccination rates rise. For example, once each state has reached, say, 20 percent of the population receiving its second dose, the agency may re-approve travel for those vaccinated. They * will * give people behavioral reasons to get the vaccine, in other words, which is good. They’re just going to do it on a sliding scale based on the total number of vaccinations, knowing that the more people who are vaccinated, the less risk there is of increased social activity for everyone.



[ad_2]

Source link