[ad_1]
In the light of recent events, it is probably not really a surprise to see Donegal hand over this week. Their recent statement regarding the first weekend of the new GAA football championship experience, when they play in Dublin at Croke Park next Saturday, says they're hoping to sit down with GAA. "to ask for clarification on how a county can use soil as both neutral and place of residence".
"The objective of the meeting is to guarantee a level playing field for each team that will qualify for the All-Ireland quarterfinal group stage and ensure that no team has no advantage over any other team. "
Stealing in this ointment is that nowhere the original motion that pbaded in Congress mentions a neutral place. He mentions a home game, an away match and a game at Croke Park. This has escaped the attention of many people, including many of those in Congress apparently, but it is there.
Super 8s
It would not be a problem if Dublin did not qualify for the Super 8s (a name I know a lot about at Croke Park is not so exciting – maybe Donegal thought that They would have more chance of getting their meeting if they used the phrase "quarter-final group stage of all of Ireland" in their statement).
But we can all say with great certainty that Dublin will be there for the next iterations of what you want to call the next round-robin phase – GAA can hardly claim to be blinded by the recent upsurge in football's fortunes. Dublin.
Just about everyone seems to have been caught cold, though. As is often the case in the GAA, outrage comes too late for us to fix it. And I think it's because we find that it's rather difficult to outrage the abstract.
But this particular outrage now has a name. . . and it's Donegal. It's very unfair on Donegal, is not it? And it will be just as unfair for Armagh or Roscommon, who have to play in Dublin on their playground / neutral / shared-with-the-Gaels-of-the-world during the last round of games. But this is not for a few weeks, so we can do it later.
To be honest, Joe.ie's Colm Parkinson had scrutinized his crystal ball, was able to predict that Dublin would sneak into the Super 8, and asked Paraic Duffy of the injustice of both Dublin games in their home last September. But everything seemed so much. . . far. I'm sure it'll work, we could have said, go against any known form.
This statement of Donegal did not arrive in a vacuum, of course. They were undoubtedly emboldened by Kildare's success in bringing Mayo to Newbridge last Saturday (and then continuing to illustrate the benefit of the home advantage and a cause to defend in the field). Leinster's final rebound for Thurles was also launched, and the Waterford situation at the Munster Championship, when they were not allowed out of the province, was also launched. in the hopper. It seemed that the GAA could not put a right foot, suddenly.
Kildare
The GAA certainly made a stint for his own return to Waterford by making the decision, but the Leinster Hurling final played at Thurles is not unfair. It may not be entirely logical. It may not have been necessary to evacuate it from the province. But this is not unfair. No team wins over playing there.
Kildare was right to set foot last week because he had earned the right to play at home. Similarly, in the interest of fairness, each Super 8 team receives a home match, an away game and a match where neither of them has a match. advantage of the house – essentially the neutral ride that was not called neutral round in the original move, because it stipulated that these games be played at Croke Park.
Dublin fans, and ex-players like Alan Brogan, pointing out that Croke Park is not the homeland of Dublin, live in the imagination. If you play all your home league games in one field, that is your home field.
Brogan tried to make the qualification that Dublin did not train in Croker, so it could not be their home field. But many counties do not train on their original grounds – they have centers of excellence for that. Argue otherwise, it's insulting the intelligence of your audience.
This does not tarnish Dublin's legacy, as Jim McGuinness has suggested. But this tarnishes even more the idea of fairness. Nothing will happen this year, because we recently understood who was getting baded here. But if Galway and Kerry can meet in a neutral place, Dublin and Donegal can do it too.
Source link
