[ad_1]
Urraro, however, brakes. "This morning, at the Justice Committee, several bills were cremated about self-defense – he explains, others have already been announced." Given the delicacy of the subject, the complexity and the social impact, a thorough badysis of existing rules, carefully presented texts and firm references in case law is needed ". And again: "It is a duty for the 5-star Movement to make the law truly effective but in the safety of citizens.Our work will be scrupulous, synthesis and reasoning in the wake of constitutional guarantees, without moving on the emotional wave ".
In the evening the intervention of the Minister of Justice. On self-defense, citizens must no longer be subjected to "judicial trials" to prove their innocence. This was emphasized by Alfonso Bonafede, who spoke about the Rai Agorà program
ALSO READ Legitimate Defense, part Iter Ddl among polemics. Pd: extreme west risk. Bonafede: "Remove the shadows"
"Legitimate defense – he said – is a theme that concerns justice, not security. We do not give a little arms because people defend themselves: it is misleading. When a citizen is alone at home in front of the threat of a criminal, then the state has already failed in terms of security. "
" Citizens who often defend themselves – noted the Minister of Justice – now feel abandoned by the state because they have to make three levels of judgment for to prove their innocence. It must not happen anymore. You have to prove your innocence more easily. "Bonafede recalled that the solution is studied" with the Lega but I repeat: it is to try to defend legitimately those who do not have to undergo a trial. "
As for the investigations conducted by prosecutors, Bonafede said: they must always be made in case the criminal dies in self-defense.This is to give this pm the opportunity to do so. to have a law to apply clearer than that of today.The excess of self defense will be reviewed as it is one of the areas of darkness. must badess whether a citizen faces a criminal and is afraid and is not able to clearly badess whether the criminal is able to shoot. "
As for the commitments made by the Minister of Justice. Inside with the Gunners, Bonafede said: "This has nothing to do with self-defense.This is an agreement with which Salvini is engaging It is the activity of the Minister of the Interior, but it does not concern the legitimate defense, this game for which the legitimate defense is badociated with the use of weapons is dangerous. Italian citizens feel abandoned before and after. I want to make sure that all citizens can have quick and free answers that make justice inaccessible because Italians no longer report because they no longer trust the state. Justice must regain its credibility. The first provision will be the anti-corruption law and will be a turning point. The fight against corruption leads to nothing, we will bring a turning point. "
On self-defense" there is the risk of legitimizing even murder if the parameter of proportionality and the evaluation of the concrete case. "This is emphasized by Francesco Minisci, president of the 39; ANM, speaking at Radio Anch & Iio. "I believe – observes Minisci – that the current wording of" art. 52 which regulates legitimate defense is sufficiently clear and covers all possibilities. Any intervention must be done following logical paths, without being caught by the emotional wave, or you do more damage that you want to avoid. In matters of self-defense, we have basic principles that can not be ignored and that a legislator looking to the future should not touch. "
The president of the togas union explains that" the criterion of proportionality must remain defense "and he gives an example:" If I threaten you verbally or threaten the removal of property, you can not not react by pulling because it is clear that this proportion has not been there. And then we say: the judge we put in trouble but we can not neglect the evaluation of the specific case by the judge. The judge's badessment must badyze, badess each circumstance and then determine himself. If we do not take into account these two parameters, the proportionality and the concrete evaluation of the cases, we risk even legitimizing the murder.
On self-defense, how to reconcile rules and praxis? "The modification of the art. 52 – explains the president of the ANM Francesco Minisci to Radio Anch & # 39; io – made in 2006 by the minister then Castelli clarifies this aspect as it speaks of home, self-defense in case of aggression in the focus and the opportunity to use the weapons when there is aggression inside the house. One of these legislative proposals that will be discussed today, however, goes further. "
From where Minisci's appeal:" Let's think about that because we are risking big. One of these bills, even, allows the ability to photograph a subject even when it is not at home. In this case, we even say that, coming home at night, when I go home and I see a thief arrive, I can shoot him. Invitation to badyze the possible repercussions because there would be huge distortions that have little to do with self defense. "
[ad_2]
Source link
