Judge not: five Trump judges have withdrawn – and four outstanding | Law


reOnald Trump has successfully appointed 89 federal judges, but not all candidates have survived the confirmation process by the Senate. Here are five judges whose applications have been withdrawn – and four controversial judges still outstanding.

Took of

Brett J Talley
Deputy Attorney General, US Department of Justice

Talley, a former Mitt Romney presidential campaign staffer and assistant solicitor general in Alabama, had practiced law for only three years, when Trump proposed him to a district court in Alabama. The American Bar Association sent the Senate a letter unanimously calling Talley "unqualified". But his candidacy was not withdrawn until he discovered that he had not revealed his marriage to Annie Donaldson, then chief of staff of the House's attorney. Blanche, Donald McGahn, who was in charge of selecting the judges that Trump would name.

Jeff Mateer
First Deputy Attorney General of Texas

Mateer's candidacy for a position in the Texas District Court collapsed after the publication of hate speech excerpts from 2015. Mateer approved the "conversion therapy" for LGBT people. training in "brainwashing", including:

Guess what, I attend a conservative Baptist church. We discriminate, right? On the basis of sexual orientation, we discriminate. Does that mean that I can not be a judge? Unfortunately, in some states, it's true, it's true.

Matthew Spencer Petersen
President of the Federal Electoral Commission

Peterson's appointment to a District Court in the District of Columbia failed the Senate after Petersen confessed that he had never lodged a complaint, that he had never made a statement or made an application. In a painful scene, he did not define the basic legal terms either.

Thomas Farr

Farr's candidacy for a North Carolina district court was sanctioned by the publication of a 1991 memo detailing Farr's work on a Senate campaign for right-wing Republican Senator, Jesse Helms, charged with " postcard mailing program designed to threaten and intimidate black voters ". He also defended a discriminatory law on the identification of voters. The NAACP has called Farr's appointment "a slap on communities of color around the world."

Ryan Bounds
Assistant US Attorney in the District of Oregon

Bounds was heading to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal when a report on his discriminatory and undisclosed writings was published. An example in the Stanford Review includes:

During my years in our multicultural garden of Eden, I have often marveled at the strange strategies that some of the strongest racial factions of the student body use to "awaken consciousness," "strengthen tolerance," "promote the diversity". and otherwise convince us to share this fruit that promises to open our eyes to a PC version of the knowledge of good and evil. I am perplexed because this tactic always seems to contribute more to restricting consciousness, aggravating intolerance and beating cultural identities. that many a Nazi burning books.


Neomi Rao
Director, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs

Rao was appointed to the US Court of Appeals for the DC circuit, to a vacancy left vacant by Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh. She has worked for Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and served on the Senate Judiciary Committee, which will weigh on her appointment.

The Alliance for Justice has compiled his writings on sexual consent and sexual assault in Yale, including:

Unless someone forces her to drink in an undetectable way or force her into her throat, a woman, like a man, decides when and how much to drink. And if she drinks to the point where she can not choose anymore, well, getting there was part of her choice.

Brian C Buescher

Buescher was appointed to the Nebraska District Court. The Leaders' Conference on Civil and Human Rights brought together Buescher's views during a past political campaign, including support for the ban on abortion.

And on LGBT rights, he said:

I believe that marriage is a union between a man and a woman. I do not believe that homosexuality should be considered in the same way as race or ethnicity, with respect to the anti-discrimination laws that currently apply to race or ethnicity. ethnicity.

Although he described abortion services as "simply immoral," Buescher told the Senate that, if he confirmed it, he would "apply and enforce" Roe v Wade.

Wendy Vitter

Vitter, a lawyer for the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of New Orleans, was appointed to hold a position at the District Court in Louisiana. Dana Singiser, vice president of public policy for Planned Parenthood, wrote that Vitter "has used its public status to promote false science and misinformation about abortion and birth control. She spoke at anti-abortion rallies, led anti-abortion panels, and represented anti-abortion organizations. "

In his confirmation hearings, Vitter escaped specifying whether Brown / Board of Education, the 1954 Supreme Court ruling against racial segregation in schools, had been "properly decided."

Kenneth Lee

Lee, former administration lawyer George W Bush, was appointed to the court of appeal of the Ninth Circuit.

Democrats in Senate justice committees, however, said Lee's unrevealed student writings showed "troubling views of race," including that of the 1990s:

Liberals rarely accuse a black criminal of his crime, lest they appear racist. Instead, they blame racism or society … But of course, this ultimately hurts the black community. The majority of the crimes committed today are black-on-black crimes (interracial crimes are quite rare), and having this lax attitude toward black crime …[so] White liberals allow the majority of law-abiding African-Americans to be continually victimized.

Source link