New York State Supreme Court Judge Ends Measles Ban in Rockland County, Calling "Arbitrary and Fickle" Practice



[ad_1]

Ed Day, a Rockland County officer, has run into a court decision today, when a New York Supreme Court Judge overruled his ban on banning everyone. unvaccinated children in public places to qualify it as "arbitrary and capricious". Supreme Court Justice Rolf Thorsen ruled in favor of the parents who challenged the Rockland County Order in court. Thorsen ruled that any emergency ban could not last more than five days, while Day wanted a ban of thirty days. The judge ordered that all children concerned by the ban be immediately returned to school and accommodated in public places, while stating that the ban could not be applied. Day had threatened non-vaccinated citizens of Rockland County to imprison for up to six months if they violated his ban.

Judge Thorsen also questioned the county's definition of a "health emergency" stating that 166 measles cases out of a population of 330,000 people do not meet the legal requirements for the outbreak.

Day has been accused of anti-Semitism and banishment from the ultra-orthodox Hasidic Jewish community. As reported in New York Timeshe caused an anti-Semitic panic.

Erica Wingate was working in a clothing store in town this week when a male client, with black hat and side covers generally worn by ultra-Orthodox Jews, began to cough.

Another client who was standing next to him suddenly dropped the article that she was holding and grabbed her child. "She bought something and she just threw it on the floor," Ms. Wingate recalls. "She said," Let's go, let's go! Jews do not have shots! "" … So some locals say they are now wiping out the bus seats and crossing the street when they see ultra-Orthodox Jews. Hassidic leaders have expressed fear not only of rising anti-Semitism, but also of an invasion of their community cloistered by the authorities under the guise of public health.

… Steve Gold, president of the Jewish Community Relations Council of the Jewish Federation of Rockland, shares Mr. Wieder's concerns, noting that the county officials' approach may exacerbate the anti-Semitism that already existed in the area. region before the measles crisis. He pointed to a number of anti-Semitic episodes, including spray-painted swastikas on trees.

"I think it just opened the door for everyone to say what they meant," Gold said. "And they give, it seems, a 100% blame to the Orthodox community."

Beyond obvious religious discrimination, the order of Day has sown confusion among business owners. The New York Times continued,

At the Rockland Kosher supermarket in Monsey, the manager, Maier Fried, stood in the Passover produce aisle, anxiously blowing on a vaporizer pen a day after the statement. He welcomed the order – a friend's child has not been able to go to school since the epidemic due to a compromised immune system, he said – but he did not know what to do about the ban and was afraid to target customers.

"How am I supposed to know who has a vaccine?", He said. "Am I asking? Do I have the right to apply it? And am I allowed to do it?

Judge Thorson's answer is no. The panic that Rockland County provoked with the ban that mainly affected Jewish children was ill-conceived and far exceeded. According to the CDC, measles has killed a person in the United States in the last ten years. In comparison, the flu killed 80,000 people last year and no county insists on banning people who do not get the flu shot in schools or grocery stores. The disparity is flagrant and at least one judge pointed out the obvious mistake of judgment.

But the attack against religious objectors in New York is not over yet. A bill to repeal religious exemptions for vaccines in state legislatures has been passed by Democrats.

[ad_2]

Source link