The Lisbon ratio alters the military decision and the conviction of GNR to pay the judge – Cm ao Minuto



[ad_1]

The Lisbon Court of Appeal (TRL) sentenced four soldiers of the GNR to a fine of 2,340 euros for slanderous and falsified denunciation of testimony and payment of 8,000 euros to Judge Neto de Moura

The decision of the TRL, to which the Lusa agency had access Tuesday, signed by the judges Carlos Espirito Santo and Cid Geraldo, amends the decision of the Loures court that acquitted the defendants in a lawsuit in 2012 when the court of Loures The assistant (Judge Neto de Moura) was supervised by a brigade GNR in the municipality of Loures, at the time he was driving without registration plates in the car.

On July 10, 2012 (day after the operation), the patrol leader prepared a contribution addressed to the Superior Council of Magistracy (CSM) to denounce that Judge Neto de Moura "saw and ignored the Order to arrest the GNR army ", and, after being intercepted, maintained a" provocative, intimidating and offensive "attitude in front of the police elements

The defendants testified as witnesses in the CSM, which closed the disciplinary investigation by deliberation of 18 September 2012, and the judge filed a criminal complaint.

The accused were acquitted by the first instance

The TRL's judgment argues that "it can not be proven" that the assistant is passed to the defendants, because the l. one of the guards said that the roundabout, where the GNR army was, was "about 30/50 meters" from the road where the judge was traveling

This soldier said that he did not could not yet guarantee that the judge was aware of the warrant for arrest,

"Attentive to the distance at which he was from the assistant, the order of arrest that has him been given was not observed by the assistant, so the defendant S "he said, pointing out that the" assistant "deliberately and consciously disobeyed this order, because he showed visible signs of having perceived the sign "and even if the" assistant "fled", "the judges, Carlos Espirito Santo and Cid Geraldo TRL points out that Judge Neto de Moura has" obeyed "all the ordr These were transmitted to him by the agents of the GNR inspectors, after being intercepted by the GNR character who followed the sound and audible signals.

"Despite the Hollywood scene, the assistant naturally expressed her dissatisfaction by saying" it's a festival ", which of course does not reflect any offensive, intimidating, provocative or aggressive behavior" emphasizes the Lisbon Relationship.

For the judges, it is clear that the patrol leader "lied" and that the other defendants confirmed the participation presented to the Superior Council

"Doubts remain that the defendant Santos lied shamelessly in his participation at the CSM, as well as in statements made in the investigation that followed, charging the assistant with the practice of a crime of disobedience that he knew well "

The TRL says that the surveillance exercised by the accused and other agents "has resulted in a vexatious spectacle", concluded the Court of Relação de Lisboa. "to the assistant, criticizing the action of the police and giving two" less favorable "examples to the police forces

" (…) those relating to the trial of the PSP agents by situations occurred in Cova da Moura (Amadora) and Guimarães (aggression against Benfica supporters), with obvious discredit for the institutions to which they belong ", remember the judges judges.

Judge Neto de Moura, currently and at the Oporto appeal court, the controversial rapporteur was a controversial judge on a domestic violence case, pending the findings of a disciplinary investigation opened by the Superior Council of the Judiciary

In the judgment, the Judge Neto de Moura morally condemns a female Felgueiras victim of domestic violence, downplaying this crime because she has committed adultery by invoking the Bible, the Penal Code of 1886 and even the civilizations that punish the crime. adultery with c the death penalty to justify domestic violence The SIC television channel, in a game on this Judgment of Relation released Monday night, states that one of the two judges who signed the decision "has already worked directly with Neto Moura "and that" he has now decided to change the sentence in favor of the magistrate. "

The SIC says that Judge Carlos Espirito Santo signed the judgment with Neto Moura, when he is The judge was working in Lisbon

[ad_2]
Source link