Pooh-Pooh One Psychologists Incredibles 2 & # 39; Point Plot

"Incredibles" is finally Bach! Wait, no, it's Mozart.

The sequel, which arrived 14 years after the original film, brought an even more adult version of humor centered on the parents of the franchise. But the character that comes out most of everyone in the movie is Baby Jack-Jack – with some classic jams.

Yes, in "Incredibles 2", it seems that Mozart is helping to bring out the new Jack-Jack superhero. shapes, some of which are fire baby, baby floating and baby monster. For the joy of the Internet the joke is clearly based on the idea that classical music, especially Mozart, could help cognitive development.

Unfortunately, if you are a parent who thinks his child could also have bad news.

First of all, we are worried about you. Second, the experts we talked about criticized the idea that listening to Mozart and his fellow countrymen would have positive effects on development, not to mention the superpowers.

Professor Christopher Chabris, cognitive psychologist at the Geisinger Health System in Pennsylvania and co-author of The Invisible Gorilla: How our intuitions deceive us said that the perception that Mozart has an effect on the development and the

"It will not surprise you to hear that there is no scientific evidence that listening to Mozart can bring out super powers in a baby or anyone else, "he said in an email. In the 1990s, many music companies released CDs and videos based on this idea, for example "Mozart makes you smarter", "Baby Mozart", which led to "Baby Einstein" and related products, he added. "However, the truth is that after many studies, there is no reason to believe that listening to Mozart's music will make anyone a smarter: not adults, no children, no babies, no fetuses.This has been known since 1999, when I published an article in Nature showing that the so-called "Mozart effect" was a stroke of luck , not a reproducible scientific effect. "

Jakob Pietschnig, a psychologist at the University of Vienna is studying" the Mozart effect ", in agreement with Chabris.

"The evidence of an effect of improving musical performance is desperately low (that is, virtually zero)," he tells us

. Impressed by Mozart's findings on growing intelligence, he said that music training is more promising.

"It is clear that the mere exposure to Mozart / classical music does nothing to improve the intelligence, but there is some evidence to suggest that musical training may be related to cognitive abilities to some extent I would not go so far to call this evidence solid, especially because the causality has not been clearly established. "

Although Jack-Jack's powers appear in "Incredibles 2", we first had a glimpse of the baby's super-potential at the end of the original film, when his multiple abilities allowed him to 39, escape the clutches of the wicked.

But the first time that Jack-Jack's powers appear appears in the short "Jack-Jack Attack", which is on the "Indestructible" DVD and covers events chronologically before the baby is captured by Syndrome. Jack-Jack's abilities manifest themselves as his babysitter plays him classical music, leading fans to speculate that Mozart was spurring his powers.

"Incredibles 2" basically confirms this theory

After Edna Mode creates a great suit to help control Jack-Jack's abilities and shows it to his father, Bob Parr, we learn that, indeed, Mozart is somehow able to bring out the powers of Jack-Jack.

Unfortunately, let 's try as we could, we could not get an expert to entertain the idea that this might be plausible in real life. Mozart will not awaken the superpowers of your baby, let alone make him more intelligent. This only happens to Jack-Jack. What may not be such a bad thing.