An imperfect update of the test bench shows that the expensive Intel Core i9-9900K is very similar to AMD Ryzen 7 2700X



[ad_1]

Intel Core i9-9900K
Intel and its committed benchmarking pistol, Principled Technologies, have been criticized for the benchmarking methodology used to validate the Core i9-9900K as the "fastest gaming processor in the world". At the heart of the problem lies the decision of the latter to activate the game mode on the AMD Ryzen 7 2700X, resulting in a 50% greater performance disparity than that of the Core i9-9900K. Since then, Principled Technologies has retried the Ryzen 7 2700X in Creator mode and, even though the new data still has the Core i9-9900K, the disparity is not as dramatic.

As you may already know, the Core i9-9900K is Intel's flagship processor in the recently announced 9th generation Core processor family. This is the first 8-core / 16-threaded consumer desktop game. It was launched in parallel with the Core i7-9700K (8-core / 8-wire) and Core i5-9600K (6-core / 6-wire) processors, all three built and benefiting from the Intel 14nm ++ manufacturing process.

At launch, Intel introduced the Core i9-9900K as the fastest gaming processor in the world. To support this claim, Intel commissioned Principled Technologies, a third-party "marketing, learning and testing services" company, to test the Core i9-9900K in a set of game criteria (19 in total) and compare results to several others. other processors. These results were released on the same day as the launch party for the 9th generation base.

Small note: Core i9-9900K performance evaluations are still embargoed until October 19th. This means that sites such as us and others are not able to compare the benchmarks we may already have with those obtained by Principled Technologies. Customers also have a single official source of reference data to decide on the pre-order of the piece. So, this is not an ideal situation.

That said, it is the test methodology used by Principled Technologies that has been the subject of careful scrutiny. Steve Burke at Nexus Gamers conducted an exclusive interview with test co-founder Bill Catchings, and in the 46-minute online video, Burke perfectly covers some of the questionable test decisions, including the type of cooling and specific parameters.

What seems to stand out from the interview and the response of Principled Technologies to the situation is that there was no malicious intent. It does not seem that the company has tried to "play" the results to favor Intel. Testing the processors and running game tests is not something that it does all the time. And on the merits of the company, after being informed of how the activation of the game mode on a traditional Ryzen processor can (and in some cases harm) game performance, she came back and has retested all Ryzen tokens with Creator mode.

"We started the game mode tests for AMD Ryzen's Threadripper processors based on AMD processors, and these results showed that the game mode offered the best gaming performance on Threadripper." the game mode on all AMD processors We did not add the results of our AMD Ryzen 7 2700X processor tests to its default mode (Creator mode), which overall generated the best gaming performance on the market. 2700X We apologize for the fact that both modes have not been tested in the initial report., "Captures says in a follow-up statement (PDF).
Ashes of singularity landmarks "width =" 625px
Click to enlarge (Source: Principled Technologies)

Switching to Creator Mode has not always made much of a difference, but there have been instances where he has done so. More often than not, it was the case, in fact. For example, in Gears of War 4, the performance advantage of the Core i9-9900K went from 46.4% to 24.9% when switching from game mode to creator mode in the AMD game. And in Ashes of the Singularity, the Core i9-9900K went from 57.2% faster to 17.7%.

Intel adopted the new results by issuing an updated statement to emphasize the initial point that the Core i9-9900K is the fastest gaming processor.

"Based on feedback from the technical community, we are pleased that Principled Technologies has done additional testing and has now published these results, with even more details on the configurations used and their rationale." The results continue to show that Core 9th Generation i9-9900K is the world's best gaming processor, we appreciate the time and transparency of Principled Technologies and we always appreciate the feedback from the technical community and we look forward to hearing from you. the full third-party reviews that will be released on October 19, "said Intel. .

That's it, the Core i9-9900K was even faster in games than the Ryzen 7 2700X, but not to the same extent as the original test methodology indicated. The question of whether Intel should have promoted the initial set of benchmarks is a more in-depth discussion.

In any case, the actual analyzes are imminent and potential buyers will soon have a much broader set of data and analyzes on which to base their decisions.

[ad_2]
Source link