The Controversial "Stanford Imprisonment Experience" Arrested After Losing Control of the Situation | Science and health



[ad_1]

This is one of the most famous social experiences in history, told so often that some consider it a myth.

You may have heard of it already: a psychology professor is recruiting a group of students and asking them to imagine that they are in jail. Designate some as guards and others as inmates.

In a few days, "jailers" become sadistic and abuse such a form of prisoners that the experience must be stopped.

It really happened in 1971 and it was not in one of the best universities in the United States – Stanford, California.

The roots of the experiment are related to another controversial experiment conducted ten years earlier in another reputed American university, Yale.

Known as the "Milgram Experience", because it had been conducted by psychologist Yale Stanley Milgram, she aimed to examine the level of obedience of individuals to the world. ;authority.

In turn, the trials of the Nazis accused of war crimes before the Nuremberg Tribunal were at the origin of their inspiration. Most of them had based their defense on the badertion that they "only took orders" from their superiors.

Milgram wanted to test how well a "good" human being was able to harm another by obedience.

His experience aroused even more controversy because he lied to the participants telling them that it was a study of memory and learning.

The scientist divided 40 volunteers into two random groups: one declared that they would be teachers and the others, that they would be students.

He then took the "students" to another room and asked the "teachers" to test the memory of their "students".

The investigator ordered them to punish those who are mistaken for electric shock. The machine they used would emit discharges ranging from 50 to 450 volts. The maximum power was accompanied by an inscription "Danger: violent shock".

  65% of <img clbad = "image content-media__image" itemprop = "contentUrl" alt = "65% of the maximum voltage & # 39; teacher & # 39; measure used in some 65% of" teachers "used the maximum voltage of the meter at one point, despite the cries of" students "in the next room – Photo: BBC" data-src = "https://s2.bildb.com

65% of "teachers" used the meter's maximum voltage at one point, despite the shouting of "students" in the next room – Fot o: BBC

About two-thirds of the "educators" used the meter's maximum voltage at one at any given time and all reached the 300-volt mark.

The device, however, does not go so far as to shock, and the cries that the "teachers" hear coming from the next room are actually recordings.

A decade later, Philip Zimbardo, professor of social psychology at Stanford University, s he wished to go further into Milgram's experience and examine how tenuous the line separating good from evil is.

He wondered if a "good" person could change his way of depending on his environment.

He then posted on the walls of the university a statement offering $ 15 a day to volunteers willing to spend two weeks in a false prison.

The study was funded by the government, which wanted to understand the origins of conflict in the US penitentiary system.

Zimbardo selected 24 students, mainly white and middle clbad, who separated them into two groups, randomly giving them the role of guardians and prisoners and asking them to return home.

In fact, the experience began abruptly: real police officers, who had agreed to participate in the project, went to the homes of the "prisoners" and arrested them, accusing them of theft.

They were handcuffed and taken to the police station, where they were enrolled and blindfolded at a so-called local jail – but which was actually the granary of the Stanford Psychology Department, which had been sufficiently transformed realistically, into a prison. [Image:EricECastrovialaBBC"title="Platesesouvientdel&#39;expériencequiainspirétroisfilmsetplusieurslivres-Photo:EricECastrovialaBBC"src="data:image/jpeg;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"/> <img clbad =" content-media__image picture "itemprop =" contentURL "alt =" Council recalls & # 39; experience that has inspired three films and several books – Photo: Eric E. Castro via BBC "title =" Council recalls experience, which inspired three films and several books – Photo: Eric E. Castro via BBC "data-src =" https://s2.glbimg.com/qiZ7W75XBGHz_L2S9gdHTLiOrME = / 0x0: 976×549 / 984×0 / smart / filters: strip_ic ())

A plaque recalls the experience, which inspired three films and several books – Photo: Eric E. Castro via BBC

The Volunteers were then required to undress, were inspected, disinfected, treated for lice and had to wear a sistia uniform in a large shirt with a number (and no other part underneath), rubber sandals and a nylon cap made with c women's tights.

Those who played the role of guards put a heavy lock on the prisoners' ankles.

What would happen next would be so shocking that it would inspire three films (one German in 2001 and two in Hollywood in 2010 and 2015), as well as several books and articles.

At the beginning of the experiment, the "guards" began to engage in abusive behavior which, in a short time, became sadistic.

Ordered not to physically injure the prisoners, the jailers committed all kinds of psychological violence with them.

For example, to identify detainees by number, they were constantly sent to solitary confinement, forced to undress, forced to push, to sleep on the floor, to put on paper bags to avoid to call them by name. in their heads and forced us to turn their needs into buckets.

"On the day of their arrival, it was a small prison set up in an attic with fake cells.On the second day, it was a real prison, created in l 39; mind of every prisoner, every guard and other people involved "Zimbardo told the BBC in 2011, when the experience took 40 years.

Several prisoners began to present emotional problems.

"One of the most effective practices (prison guards) has been to interrupt sleep, a known torture technique," said BBC's Clay Ramsey, one In 1965, however, only a few students asked to leave the study before it was actually interrupted.

Dave Eshleman, one of the young men who played the role of jailer, remembers that he viewed the experience as a kind of theatrical exercise.

"The first day, nothing happened, it was a little boring, so I decided to play the role of a very cruel jailer," he said. -he declares.

The so-called "Stanford prison experience" reached such a level of perversity that it had to be suspended less than a week after it began.

The study lasted only six days, but Zimbardo had time to conclude that the environment influences human behavior and that placing "good" people in a bad place can cause them to behave like bad people. or resign yourself to being mistreated.

The theory – ultimately regarded as the realization that we are all sadists or potential masochists – has been hotly contested over the years,

The main question was the role of Zimbardo himself, who for the experience had served as a "director" of the prison and would have advised the guards to behave and encouraged abusive behavior. Despite the controversy, however, Zimbardo, who has gained notoriety and is now considered a great name in his field, continues to defend his experience as a very valuable contribution to psychology, which would have served to understand phenomena such as the abuses committed. in the Iraqi prison of Abu Ghraib.

"Experience shows us that human nature is not totally subject to free will, as we like to think, but that most of us can be seduced and become totally atypical. about what we believe to be, "told the BBC.

[ad_2]
Source link