All indications are that the dam broke by liquefaction, according to the authority of Minas Gerais | Minas Gerais



[ad_1]

The rupture of the Vale dam last Friday (25) may have been caused by liquefaction, a problem that only occurs in systems built upstream by the uplift, as in the Brumadinho (MG) structure, the Undersecretary for Environmental Regulation Secretary of State for the Environment, Hidelbrando Neto.

Decommissioning: Understanding the process announced by Vale

However, it would be necessary to understand why liquefaction would have occurred, said the undersecretary, because the data provided by Vale show this equipment called piezometers n & # 39 did not detect the internal movement of water in the structure.

<img clbad = "content-video__placeholder__thumb" src = "https://s03.video.glbimg.com/x720/7347202.jpg" alt = "The video shows the exact moment when the mud breaks the Brumadinho dam "title =" The video shows the exact moment when the mud breaks the Brumadinho dam [NetoaraselfliquidfactionwiththeagainstwatercapacityintheinfrastructurewasthatthearaboutSamarco'sarrangement(undertakenbyValCommunitywithBHPBilliton)inNovember2015whichusedtheemethodofmanage

The conclusion in the Samarco case was published by the authorities and then confirmed by a study subcontracted by the miners themselves, which indicated technical causes of liquefaction but did not report the culprits.

"The two disasters involved upstream dams and in both cases, at least that this is the information we receive here is liquefaction, "said Neto, pointing out that ns another method of building bars

"So I think the Union will walk the path to stop, ban, these dams upstream, what the state did", did he added, pointing out that the government of Minas Gerais had been stopped any license involving any type of dam until the country revises its regulations, in addition to prohibiting the application of the technology in upstream, in a decree of 2016.

  A dam in Brumadinho used the method of upstream amounts - Photo: Karina Almeida and Alexandre Mauro / G1   Brumadinho dam used the method of elevation for the amount - photo: Karina Almeida and Alexandre Mauro / G1 "title =" Brumadinho elevation dam used the quantity method - Photo: Karina Almeida and Alexandre Mauro / G1 "data-src =" https://s2.glbimg.com/J0YP51zMRBoJwDqatveWk7f27_F=/0x0:1700x800 / 984x0 / s </source></source></source></source></source></picture> </div>
<p clbad= The Brumadinho Dam used the met hode of (a), (b) and (b) and (b) Vale stated that "the causes of the disturbance are the subject of an investigation and that they will be communicated in a transparent manner and with the greatest possible agility ". Photo: Karina Almeida and Alexandre Mauro / G1

The authorities also pointed out that some factors that can sometimes precipitate problems in the dams have not been verified.

"There was no tremor, there was no rain, which are usually triggers." The question everyone asks is: what happened?

The break-up of Vale's dam on Friday killed at least 110 people, 71 of whom were identified and more than 200 missing.

The upstream system costs about half of the other dams, but presents a higher security risk because its walls are built on a waste base rather than an external material or solid soil.

  Understanding iron ore, tailings and dam - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "title =" Understanding iron ore, tailings and dam - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "src =" data: image / jpeg; base64, / 9j / 4AAQSkZJRgABAQAAAQABAAD / 2wBDAAMCAgMCAgMDAwMEAwMEBQgFBQQEBQoHBwYIDAoMDAsKCwsNDhIQDQ4RDgsLEBYQERMUFRUVDA8XGBYUGBIUFRT / 2wBDAQMEBAUEBQkFBQkUDQsNFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBT / wgARCAAnABkDASIAAhEBAxEB / 8QAGgAAAwADAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAUGAgMECP / EABcBAAMBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABAgP / 2gAMAwEAAhADEAAAAfRG9e6VraGcpAl8HM9OtV0y9RWXDkCa5uDj / 8QAHhAAAwEBAAEFAAAAAAAAAAAAAgMEBQAQAQYSEyH / 2gAIAQEAAQUCCWQwGFJckZwbyc8ICR6fLptRR38yyNrZ7J3NFC / DSSktLegwwyvcmdseF / VWts6jSvPQlv53 / 8QAGxEBAQEBAAMBAAAAAAAAAAAAAQIAERIiMTL / 2gAIAQMBAT8BskfV1RUfrQFPIHuual5Ws8bQyr93 / 8QAGhEBAQACAwAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQAhMRARYf / aAAgBAgEBPwE9h7nG4R1GTj // xAAnEAABAgMHBAMAAAAAAAAAAAACAQMAERIEECExMkFSEyJRkTM0cf / aAAgBAQAGPwKplvqCvBYmrRCo5TWBIWiq / bvtGo8NoUhOY5SplBWYUREyEk3W7B7uU ngm8MAD + + + + JzIRVM40D6u MatWW8Wdy1N k0hzQCBupEXxhErNaRI0zbLtL1cjlOC YoNoXA4kk4rbZFtU4NikaI // 8QAIhAAAgIBAwQDAAAAAAAAAAAAAREAITEQQVFhgaHwccHx / 9oACAEBAAE / IRFjG6IC9ggQYNtNl2eiJlAc7cgQZdh0gbP6F5Hv GgbTTF2w / gtlBTPxACw90V0QmOqDufPWFNqUdwYKJ8x7xmDnde0cRjkOCNV9REzOIPmXSQiQHRiP8hP / 2gAMAwEAAgADAAAAEFQVOHg 8QAGxEBAAICAwAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQARMUEhUaH // / // 2gAIAQMBAT8QoNxGQFWXLJSxh06qIzRNM6IL4zlVc EABkRAQADAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEAESExQf / aAAgBAgEBPxBKY2BoiRaKgFrI6F9gByf / xAAfEAEBAAMBAQACAwAAAAAAAAABEQAhMUFREGFxkfD / 2gAIAQEAAT8QiWFulHZtDq4NCDK0NvDO3D2RjO6vND185kf3 / WFE6ODrVeP7XHkLYoevdsGfxlYMQAo1fIQfa + + mG6NNgTSc5rvLj1SQ5sE5oPXZTI6hQGie8 mU / E4LUfGSo0jXqZVDZsD4yChrRljhcYQD4VnsJ1dbyPpkw1w0VLWOCRSJXbRllF7hxNRHsoKh4npn7H + F3N // Z "/> <picture itemscope=   Understanding what is iron ore, residues and dam - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "title =" Understand iron ore, tailings and dam - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "data-src =" https://s2.glbimg.com/Y6yas0Jmvpupb73gjsLP1RR9T64 = / 0x0 : 1600x2491 / 984x0 / smart / filters: strip_icc () / i.s3.glbimg.com/v1/AUTH_59edd422c0c84a8 "</source></source></source></source></source></picture> </div>
<p clbad= Understand the iron ore, the tailings and the dam – Photo: Alexandre Mau ro / G1

An Alternative to Iron Ore, Residue and Dam – Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1

This is the downstream method, when walls are built on dry ground, in addition to other technologies, such as dry residue disposal, cavas or piles.

With nearly 12 million cubic meters of iron ore tailings, the structure that served the Córrego do Feijão mine released a mountain of mud that engulfed the company's administrative area and a dining hall with hundreds of employees. the society. It has also reached the communities, inns, forests and rivers of the region.

There are currently 50 dams upstream in Minas Gerais, of which 27 are in operation and 23 are paralyzed, including Brumadinho.

The State Secretary for the Environment and Sustainable Development of Minas Gerais is responsible for issuing licenses for dams in the state.

But Neto pointed out that the competence to inspect the dams is federal and that, through the public statements already presented by the government and the National Mine Agency (ANM), the legislation should be amended.

The changes, he said, should occur mainly on issues related to technical parameters indicating that the dam is stable.

"Because when you take both disasters, and in both cases, you have reports guaranteeing stability, then you have to review some technical parameters," said Neto.

"ANM has already issued a statement in which it says that will reinforce the inspection and start with that of the upstream dams that are without guarantee of stability," he said.

  A firefighter observes the mud that invaded the Bean Stream in Brumadinho, a few days after the fall of the dam - Photo: Mauro Pimentel / AFP   firefighter observing the mud swept Feijão Creek in Brumadinho, a few days after the fall of the dam - Photo: Mauro Pimentel / AFP "title =" A firefighter observes the mud that invaded Bean Creek in Brumadinho, a few days after the fall of the dam - Photo: Mauro Pimentel / AFP "data-src =" https://s2.ambbimg.com/wxKXT7XWzR1hQch8 "</source></source></source></source></source></picture> </div>
<p clbad= The firefighter observes the mud that was taking care of the bean stream in Brumadinho, a few days after the eighth century.Neto felt that although the skill to control the security of the dams is federal, the State Secretariat for the Environment has already taken steps to reinforce rigor, such as the prohibition of any new licensing processes for Upstream technology since 2016. [1 9659030] In addition, he also participated in a state resolution that provided for extraordinary technical safety audits for upstream buses, among other measures.

Neto estimates that the regulations around this type of dam became stricter after the disaster of Samarco, without changing the technical parameters of the badessment.

"What happened most recently was a change of direction, the technical badysis remains the same, all the same … The organ was more efficient, but met the same standards and parameters techniques, "he said. The state of Minas Gerais has already ordered to remove them all, but there is a dam upstream in Brazil, so it must act of a federal change. "

Vale recently announced that it has 10 upstream mining dams, all out of business, and announced $ 5 billion in investments to accelerate the dismantling of these structures.

This week, the company stated that 39, in 2016, shortly after the Samarco event, it had determined the decommissioning of the 19 existing dams located upstream of the iron ore in Brazil.

In recent years, all have become inactive and maintained their stability reports issued by specialized and independent companies, according to Vale.

To speed up the process of dismantling dams, the company said that it will have to stop iron ore production in the areas close to the units located in Minas Gerais, with an impact of 40 million tonnes of iron ore, which will be partially offset by the increase in production in other systems. my production of the company.

  Understanding the process of dismantling the dams - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "title =" Understanding the process of dismantling the dams - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1 "src =" data: image / jpeg; base64, / 9j / 4AAQSkZJRgABAQAAAQABAAD / 2wBDAAMCAgMCAgMDAwMEAwMEBQgFBQQEBQoHBwYIDAoMDAsKCwsNDhIQDQ4RDgsLEBYQERMUFRUVDA8XGBYUGBIUFRT / 2wBDAQMEBAUEBQkFBQkUDQsNFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBQUFBT / wgARCABJABkDASIAAhEBAxEB / 8QAGwABAAIDAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAABAIDBQYHAAH / xAAWAQEBAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAwT / 2gAMAwEAAhADEAAAAe / 3gLPVuC8bk6ZSV2TPt5kg7iyPMpQHJXYIXXI1rTOjZGWsSozrk EACMQAAIBBAEDBQAAAAAAAAAAAAECAwAEBRETBhASISIjMTT // / + 2gAIAQEAAQUCMCbS0QmBEiFZixyryY 0y0KwccnaRpdsSzqo7M3zGQcjPqWjM3lxqaa3LPqpJx5coIhGhTLqudxUUrOaeG43HDMD7q9azONGXtLXprJWMsUxVeUVjPxP9dv / xAAfEQABAwMFAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABAgMREBITMEFxgbH / 2gAIAQMBAT8BwjHfeON9APKZltMdgH0U / 8QAGhEAAQUBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQIQERIhMP / aAAgBAgEBPwG2xHCoVpb / xAA0EAABAgQDAwcNAAAAAAAAAAABAhEAAxIhBBAxImFxBUFRUoGR0hMUICMyM0JioaKx0fD / 2gAIAQEABj8Cp8ivXrj xQKsNNT81Y8UUyzbod8kK5MxqJCfilzEjvBYwfPZshaxcTEzFX4jTuiyWPOxy2aRxgWSYs3ZkLwzxrkQJZLb4emHfJqVOOcNHt / SLFxwycbW6PcxtIpyLYqm / VH6gPiirdSI1GVMrEzcNNF0zpB / nhM1PLU0tqJssqB 6PWGs9IDZI7fz6H + // xAAjEAACAgEDBAMBAAAAAAAAAAABEQAhMRBBcVFhgaEgkeGx / 9oACAEBAAE / IQDZG4JqBs2ySvRQ8dC9tLiswR8PIvENvpJScUPBUhEiUxHcaCUA94whN3ANnc6EiwwlAxyYgAChwlpastgmeBm7EMhFEvicjG1zr9EQXB6ZwPVWqaHcXce / ERbA74i4SrvQpgBJbPaDCpslePAi / o8pHjPQohO0Oz6eAo08XAUJRdsfucs93 + + LOQ / wf aAAwDAQACAAMAAAAQk8o04U8cSQ xAAeEQEAAQIHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABMQARITBRYXGRof // // / // aAAgBAwEBPxDDF13WciB0uQmRAstpKPtTX EABwRAAEDBQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEQEbEwMUFxgf / aAAgBAgEBPxB9 / vE0C1e4SIKf / 8QAJBABAQACAQQBBQEBAAAAAAAAAREAITEQQWFxUYGhsdHwkeH / 2gAIAQEAAT8QNevJAqCEJwahzstwaoocPlET0LhU1K5Bdu6 / fPoyt2Lr8iQvZWuETY7XuK3dndh2OwJsyi6hNKb0pybDjorC + hd / ImQjoCn6pu6fz4xiEqdwzosqEq935nrv2xsgHGNrGcevvjTYT2E8d / fbpwkoo9XmLlfchyVwiLcIr8Jn9nK4aBWj4vDw5GL0 + F / mScxiMq34PnojfbQD + h + 35wI14EJj3Od Jm56IId + / ++ R6PMaJUOylcHziSPjSzoUGa5JzjDVPf95P8AtfvE0h30OkSNIpolETAg0h1UUYqksQsTDeiERDbFSvBWfLn9p inl9mHL0 // 9k = "/> <picture itemscope=   Understanding the process of dismantling dams - Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1

Understanding the process of decommissioning dams – Photo: Alexandre Mauro / G1

[ad_2]
Source link