[ad_1]
Brasília, 27 – Minister Gilmar Mendes of the Federal Supreme Court (STF) said on Wednesday that the STF "was like being supreme". The Minister's statement followed his refusal of the existence of a division in the second chamber of the Court. He was commenting on the extraordinary session yesterday, which imposed five defeats on Lava Jato's minister, Edson Fachin.
For Gilmar, the concession of freedom to the former minister Jos Dirceu – one of the decisions of yesterday – normal, "without news". Asked whether the case of Dirceu could set a precedent for the release of former president Luiz Incio Lula da Silva (PT), Gilmar responded with a "wait."
Asked that the release of the former minister would be a retaliation against Fachin, who sent Lula's appeal to the plenary of the Court and to the second panel, Gilmar protested and asked that the ministers be treated with more "seriousness".
"Let's break the debate, treat people more seriously, it sounds like gossips," he complained.
Gilmar, who often diverges from Lava Jet's reporter in the second clbad and was a harsh critic of the methods of the operation, denied that the clbad was divided. The minister also said that the plenary of the Court has made "good decisions", and that the court "returns to a plan of greater institutionalization".
"The recent decision on the issue of coercive sentences clearly indicates what should be the legal standard governing the step. I think it was an important victory for the rule of law. Paulo Bernardo, I think the court here also said what his meant, I think we are walking well, the Supreme being supreme again.
The Gleisi-Paulo Bernardo case cited by the minister was the trial that acquitted last week the senator and president of PT Gleisi Hoffmann and her husband, former minister Paulo Bernardo, for the crimes of pbadive bribery and money laundering in Lava Jato.
At the time, Fachin and the Dean of the Court, Celso de Mello, were defeated votes, because they understood that there was a crime of electoral lie in the case . Most ministers – Ricardo Lewandowski, Gilmar Mendes and Dias Toffoli – however argued that the senator could not be condemned only with the word of informants, and that there was no other evidence able to corroborate with the winning women.
Fachin also commented today earlier, the results of the decision yesterday in the second clbad, stating that "juzes do not have any wins or defeats." And neither one nor the other ideology, for "hanging on a side A or side B".
"The collegiate formed by distinct positions, natural dissent and therefore, to the same extent, judgments were given and will illuminate the constitutional normative order, each magistrate applying what he infers from the Constitution." It was a day of normal activity. So, that is and be so, "said the rapporteur Lava Jato.
Speaking of former President Lula, Fachin said the magistrate must leave his personal convictions "outside the courtroom".
"So I behaved and it gives me peace in the soul," concluded the minister.
The rapporteur, who recorded a series of defeats in second clbad, decided Monday to send Lula's appeal to the plenary court to suspend his arrest. The members of the second clbad believe that the Lava Jet reporter did this as a maneuver to avoid another defeat in the collegiate.
As revealed by the State Column last Friday, the ministers examined, in examining the PT's defense motion, the possibility that Lula would go under house arrest, but without altering the effects of her sentence. , like ineligibility.
(Amanda Pupo)
Source link
